Sonic the Hedgehog Review

I don't know if it's just me but I am finding this game a lot harder than when I played it back in the days! I can't even get past Marble Zone on one continue! LOL

Is there anything to say, its Sonic!!! Where it all began, a game that needs no introduction apart from the sound of..."SEGAAAAAA". Legend!

This is a timeless classic, I love it! The graphics are amazing, is it just me or did Sonic 3 look really crappy compared to this?

Actually as much as i loved Sonic 2, i thought this game was rather rushed and glitchy. 5 stars huh? i think you guys need to be a tad more critical in your reviews. so your saying this game is just as good as Super Mario World? I think not! 4 stars i'd say.

Heretic! I do prefer Sonic 2 as well, but the original Sonic is FAR from rushed and glitchy. It is a very complete game. I would rate Super Mario World higher but if it's a choice between 4 and 5 stars then both would have to get 5 out of 5. They are genre defining platformers, both special and timeless for different reasons.

Alright Dazza, ill take you up on that. Here is why i think the first Sonic diserves 4 stars (im not telling you to change the review or anything cause its your opinion, im just saying in general).

Sonic games are always about being "really fast and cool, fast SPEED man you cant even keep up man this thing is so fast!" here is how it actually works: Sonic himself has the slowest momentum of any character out there, start him from the bottom of a hill and have him walk up the hill, it takes like 2 minutes! luckly the speed boost saved that in sonic 2. there are momements early in the game where you go really fast for short periods of time without any real threats, and the general public is like, wow thats so fast, sonic is cool! ya try going that fast in the later stages, you will get hit by spikes or some random enemy/obstical within 3 seconds. The truth is in the later stages you cant go fast at all because when you do you cant see whats in front of you and the levels are designed in such a way that you will get the rings knocked out of ya if you dont watch your step.

and whats with the slooow moving platforms in the later stages. take springyard zone for example, those vertical blocks make you wait forever to get where you are going. or in marble zone riding those blocks on the lava took awhile as well. most of the time in the game is just spent waiting on other platform objects. phht "fast", mario could run laps around sonic in a practical sense.

ya there are many glitches in the game, you telling me you never been wrongfully crushed? You never landed on spikes and have the transparency not work? there are many specific examples i can give but its kind of hard to describe the scenario via text. But lets say your under water and while being pushed up a narrow space you are hugging the left side of the wall to avoid spikes right above you, however when you reach the top of the narrow space you get thrown all the way to other end of the narrow space via glitch and hit dem spikes resulting in death (happend to me several times), this was in the black and white Labyrinth Zone level. Just being crushed when your not supposed to is the worst, im sure it happend to you enough times to know what im talking about it.

Now do you see that kind of thing happening to you in Super Mario World? ofcourse not, because it wasnt rushed out to the market to try and compete with a compeitor. Nintendo took its time to make a nice quality platformer, sure the graphics in sonic look more vibrant than mario but this sonic game is all flash and no substance.

Hehe some good points. As I said before I do think Super Mario World is the better game. That being said no little niggles like you describe ultimately spoil what is a quality platformer.

On the basis that I believe Sonic 2 to be the best Sonic in the series on the Megadrive I would give this 4 stars out of 5 but not comparing it to the sublime Super Mario World.

Anyway Damo wrote the review. You'll have to take it up with him now!

I have no idea what you guys are babbling about - This deserves 5 stars by far and it is the best incarnation of Sonic ever. Sonic 2 had the speed but was too short/easy and Sonic 3 was easier yet. S&K was close second to Sonic 1.

This was my first download and I've been really impressed. It has brought the old megadrive days flooding back. Top notch.

i love this game but i got this on sonic mega collection plus so i'm not getting it
SEGAAAAAAAA!!!

I love this game more than any thing. I played this as a kid all the time. I could set my eyes on that game early morning on June 1 till late afternoon july 31. this is a game that I strongly reccomend but I hope that they will put other sonic classics on the virtual console . There is one last thing i need to say "Go Sonic".

Sonic 1 is not the best sonic, but it does deserve at least one playing. Hopefully the future of VC will bring us Sonic 2, Knuckles, and so on..

Is it still worth it if you have a 50ghz pal tv ?

I grew up playing the PAL (slower) version of the game, so it's not really a big deal for me.

I bought this on PAL version and yes its slow and very glitchy, even more so than the MD version.
Still a quality game though, but never the same rating as SMW oe LoZ:LTTP.

I have to say, i wasnt going to get this one. My GF was giving me greif about how long it was taking to get my Wii conected to the wifi for the first time and how bored she was- not to mention the guilt trip for getting yet more games.

once i downloaded this though, it all turned 180, she was on at me all weekend to be playing sonic. Infact, she wanted to stay up playing sonic rather than get an "early" night.

amazing- if i had turned down her advances so i could play zelda etc i would have been hung drawn and quartered- in vinegar probably!

The power of the VC- even turns your GF into a gamer!

and its a bloody top game!

After many failed attempts, Sega finally found it's mascot in Sonic. The beauty of Sonic was that it represented what Sega stood for, bringing the excitement of the coin-ops into your home. Sonic did this to perfection. The fastest gameplay we'd ever seen in a platform game and bags of colour and action thrown in for good measure.

It might lack the depth of gameplay of Nintendo's 16-bit mascot vehicle Super Mario World, but then SMW lacks the instant appeal that Sonic gives you.

As for the VC version, it's a bit of a let down. After we Brits were introduced to 'full speed Sonic' on the retrospective Sonic Mega Collection pack on the GC, this is a real slap in the face - especially as you can play the Mega Collection version on the Wii. Rather than download this, I'd track down an old copy of Sonic Mega Collection instead - it'll might cost you a touch more, but you'll get every single 'classic Sonic' (at full speed) in one pack.

I'm a Sonic fan no matter what. The coolness of a Sonic game should make alot of fans who are more towards Mario a bit jealous at times. Even though the two are no longer rivals anymore, it's good look back sometimes, but not too much. Speaking of rivals, does anyone know if Crash Bandicoot is still a rival of Mario (even if he is on other platforms)?

As much as I love Sonic, I think it's easy to spot a few things that would shave off that fifth star.
- No spindash, once you've played Sonic 2, you can barely play without it. This could be added easily!
- Gameplay elements that slow down the action too much, prime examples of this are Marble zones block pushing and lava "boat" riding, and pretty much the entire Labyrinth zone.
- The bonus level was very tedious to control, even though I personally loved it.

uh I've never played this before but I played sonic and the secret rings and i loved it. I might get since number two is coming out.

But I'm just worried if I keep downloading these games I'll run out of room on my wii and i wont be able to get paper Mario! Does anyone know how to get more room? Or is that what the SD card is for?

You can indeed store games on the SD slot. The good news as well is that if your SD card breaks, or you delete the game from your Wii, you can download the game again from Nintendo for free I believe, as they store your console's ID on their systems.

Thanks Mr 64

I just downloaded this game last night I love it. But you can't save so if you get a game over you have to start all over again. But I guess that's what makes the game a challenge. Does anyone know how to get more lives?

It doesn't matter if you have Sonic Mega Collection, it won't let you save where you left off. It only saves Sonic 3 data. In a way, it is kind of worth buying. Still, I am waiting for Sonic 2.

Sonic 1 on Mega Collection is an updated Japanese version with scrolling clouds and easier levels. But this version is the game that pulled me into console gaming back in 1991! And, yes, I'd give it 5 out of 5 stars too!

hm i dont have game but im sure i will like, my goal is to beat all of sonic games ever made, so this will be on list for me thank u

Amazing game and almost as good as the second one. It can feel pretty slow at times comparing to later games, but that doesn't really matter. Download it NOW!

Well, this is the game that started it all, until Sega killed it all by making Sonic a showcase for bad 3D engines and annoying sidekicks.

Sonic the Hedgehog is a beautiful game. I got Sonic with my Mega Drive, along with that bundled crapfest Altered Beast. It's incredible that its (Sonic's) graphics still look great after all these years, and I still like to play it once in a while, even though I could probably beat it with my eyes closed (well, except for that stupid Labyrinth Zone boss, that is). And there is music to match the graphical beauty, with classics like Green Hill Zone and Star Light Zone.

This game starts fast and furious and progressively becomes slower and more complicated until the claustrophobic Labyrinth Zone. Then there is a breath of air in the beautiful Star Light Zone before it gets more bureaucratic as it gets closer to the end. Overall, this progression works well.

If for some weird reason you didn't play this game on the Mega Drive or one of its many re-releases, I still recommend that you buy it. It's a great platformer that hasn't aged. If you are only going to get one Sonic game, though, wait for the release of "Sonic 3 & Knuckles". Do not settle for either Sonic 3 alone or Sonic & Knuckles alone. The combined game is the best Sonic game ever, and the highest achievement in Mega Drive platforming.

the first game i ever owned. and it kicks! i'd play this over mario.

always felt sorry for amiga that their hedgehog game 'fire and ice' got over shadowed by sonic.

great game, pretty tricky levels and fantastic boss battles. evil_ernie is right much better than mario but not as good as sonic 2 although this one is significantly harder.

A must have

get lots of coins on the bonus levels and then after you get a lot of coins then you will hear a little tune, that means that you got an extra continue

I'd give this game a 5 because it was the first in its series and they were simply trying to find out general concepts of what worked, rather than having a refined formula to base your new game off, which is what Sonic 3 and Sonic & Knuckles were privileged to have!

Sure some sidekicks are annoying, but that doesn't mean I don't like playing as them. In fact, when you have Tails by your side, he can be of use. For example, if Sonic misses some rings or power ups, Tails will grab them for you.

Asherdude- Are you saying that Sonic on mega collection has been updated? And isn't the original Megadrive release?

The Mega Collection defaults to the Japanese version, which featured improved parralex scrolling, graphical underwater effects, and the level select in the correct zone order. For example, in Green Hill Zone, the clouds would quickly move from right to left. A few codes could also let you play the original US version without these upgrades, as well as a second revision of the Japanese version which fixed the spike bug.

Thanks Josh. I believe if you select the 50Hz option (on mega collection) then you can play the original PAL Version of the game as default?

I still remember seeing this game for the first time at a freinds house and could not beleive the speed i was seeing. Its where sonic started and its still a good platform game to play with nice colours, good speed and challenging platform action.

I have Sonic Mega Collection, but I owned the Genesis bundle with both Sonic 1 and 2. Undeniably an amazing classic. What can I say? This game has been featured in various compilations, so it's impossible to avoid (unless you've been a Nintendo gamer all your life and the fact that Sonic edges out Mario).

Wow, this was the first game I played EVAR. The only reason this is 4/5 because of the some seriously slow levels, which is the big way Sonic 2 managed an edge over other platformers. I won't download this purely because I still play my Megadrive, with turbo and slow buttons for random amusement

I guess this means Nintendo FINALLY got blast processing.

(that's a joke btw)

A great classic that stands the test of time, Sonic the Hedgehog is still a fun game to play.

it isnt the first ever sonic game. the one on the master system is the best.

As anyone else noticed that the auto jump (holding down any one of the wiimote buttons) causes Sonic to continiously jump making some of his jumps shorter. Or is it just me.

If you're going to get a Sonic game I recommend getting Sonic 2. This original one is much slower based and platform oriented as this was the first in the series and they hadn't figured out that Sonic was best when running through the stages. Still an ok game but as I don't recommend it it will have to do with 2 starts from me.

I loved this game. I may get it on Wii, I may not... since I have my megadrive in the same room though, I doubt it ;P The music is catchy, it's very easy to pick up and play and gets harder as you go along: the definition of a good game.

So difficult, but lots of fun. I never played it as a kid and the VC operation manuel is never ever really good. Can anyone tell me what collecting chaos emeralds does?

It gives you an alternate ending once you beat Dr. Robotnik in the Final Zone.

Sonic just doesn't stand the test of time in the same way that Mario does. Fun, but dated...

4 stars, because it's mangled by one of the worst 50hz conversions I have ever seen.

Legend of a game. Catchy tunes, simple but fun gameplay, but as TwinCross above me said, the 50hz version is a shambles. Although on my pal MegaDrive as a kid I was oblivious to the difference between it and the original speed.
No need for me to purchase this or the others as I have Mega Collection

Just saying that #2 is much better, if you can only afford one, get #2.

Poor Sonic, always finishing second to Mario (in my world). Nice game but no gem.

i have it already, and it is very fun....and that is my two cents

i have it already, and it is very fun....and that is my two cents

It's a great game but it could be better.

The best game on the Sega. Sonic is awesome! It is deffinitly a game that is amazing still today. I haven't completed it yet
though <=( Igot to the very last level and died. It's a hard game.

The bonus stages are my favorite!

This game works for all ages. My 7 year old daughter and 5 year old son can't get enough of it ...... I need to buy them a classic controller soon

Jimmy Damage, try not to start any fanboyism, okay. This isn't 1991-2001, anymore.

If there is a Master System version of the game, dosen't that mean that this is a remake?

@zelda freak: The game won't be hard if you use cheat codes!
http://www.cheatscodesguides.com/genesis-cheats/sonic-the-hedgehog/

I believe the Genesis version came first.

For all of the people demanding that Sonic 1 have 4 stars, let me say something.

First of all, this game was the original Sonic game. Obviously Sonic 2 was a better game simply out of needing to improve upon their first major hit game. Which they did.

But in the end, if there was no Sonic 1, there would have been no Sonic 2, with which to try and improve UPON.

Sonic 1 bashers, to this say still annoy me. Because they have a bizarre and blurred grasp on the idea of the passage of time. And they base their own opinions soley of this complete ignorance as to the simplicity of how time progress forward in a linear fashion.

It's one of those things that everyone should know. The future comes AFTER the present and the present comes AFTER the past. No duh, right? Not for people that like to talk down about Sonic 1.

You people seem to act as if Sonic 2 was already finished and developed when Sonic 1 was created, the way you people seem to love whining about how it's apparently some sort of "downgrade"

The fact is that this game was a major invention and a masterpiece all it's own that was further expanded upon in the FUTURE installment.

That being said, Sonic 1 cannot and should not ever be compared in terms of quality to it's sequel which, at the time did not even exist.

If Sonic 1 were not the damn good game that it is, that actually built Sega up to a directly competing franchise against Nintendo, thereby deserving the ultimate of praise (5 stars), there would never have been the "better" sequel, because the demand would just not be there.

As the original, as a classic, from a historical standpoint, and even by today's standpoint, Sonic The Hedgehog, cannot be denied it's place as a 5 star title simply because some sequel that came out later IMPROVED upon the foundation of Sonic AFTER the fact.

This game, reviewed on it's own merits, and without being compared to the sequel, deserves.. no, DEMANDS 5 stars.

And last time I checked, that's what a good, constructive review does. Judges a game on it's own merits. Not based on what came before or what came after.

You four star advocates... shame on you.

This is the game that sold me on the Genesis in 1992. Before I saw it, I was getting a SNES. But after one look, I was a Sega fanboy!

Karma said it all. Props to you, bro.

It’s a decent game but I kind of find this version overhyped since the music feels a bit average when compared to Sonic 2 and 3. And there’s no since of speed either. Only for those who really loved sonic 2 and 3 and want more sonic action.

ok its good but i think sonic is better

Is this EU version still slow or is that fixed?

I have Sonic 1 and 2 on a compilation disc, and this series is the most overestimeted in the business. Not bad at all, but it's not even close to super mario bros 2, the least popular in mario saga